458 cases · 37 threads
Show
1950 · Between El Indio, Texas, and Guerrero, Coahuila, Mexico, about 75 mi southeast of Del Rio

El Indio-Guerrero crash (6 December 1950)

Lead
Strength D · 3/10
Evidence 1/4 · Witnesses 1/3 · Backing 1/3

A disputed briefing document, one local witness found decades later and a matching air-defense alert.

Plausibility Moderate
Score 7 · 7 factors for, 1 against

A local witness and a same-day air-defense alert support the date in the MJ-12 briefing document; the document's authenticity is disputed and nothing else is public.

See the factors ↓

Unresolved
A nearly incinerated craft in burnt ranchland between El Indio and Guerrero, with a military convoy arriving, as the accounts describe it (6 December 1950). · Illustration for uaptrail.com
When6 December 1950
WhereBetween El Indio, Texas, and Guerrero, Coahuila, Mexico, about 75 mi southeast of Del Rio

The MJ-12 "Eisenhower briefing document" says that on 6 December 1950 a craft came down almost incinerated between El Indio, Texas, and Guerrero, Mexico, and that the wreckage went to the Atomic Energy Commission's Sandia facility. In 1990-94 Dennis Stacy found a local witness, Senor Flores, who saw a fireball fall and start a grass fire and a military convoy from Piedras Negras haul something away. A national air-defense alert on 6 December 1950 and an FBI memo two days later match the date. Todd Zechel's alleged Air Force document has never been shown.

How plausible · Moderate

A local witness and a same-day air-defense alert support the date in the MJ-12 briefing document; the document's authenticity is disputed and nothing else is public.

  • ●●
    Checkable details check out The alert, the FBI memo and Stacy's article exist.
  • ●○
    Access Flores saw the fall and the convoy.
  • ●○
    No gain sought Nothing sold by the witness.
  • ●○
    Independent convergence The 6 Dec alert and 8 Dec FBI memo match the date.
  • ●○
    Fits the documented skeleton Fits the AEC/Sandia custody pattern.
  • ●○
    Fits secrecy practice A convoy cleared the site.
Against
  • −
    Lone source, no corroboration One local witness; the core claim is in one disputed document.

Plausibility weighs how well an account fits where secrecy hides the documents by design, so missing records never count against it. Strength measures what is documented. Assessed 2026-10-24.

On the record

  • The 6 December 1950 air-defense alert and the 8 December 1950 FBI memo.
  • Dennis Stacy, "Crash at El Indio", Omni (1995).

Claims

A nearly incinerated craft came down between El Indio and Guerrero on 6 Dec 1950, and the wreckage went to the AEC's Sandia facility.Majestic 12Sandia National LaboratoriesThe Eisenhower Briefing Document (18 November 1952)The 1950s Del Rio, Texas UFO CrashesanonymousLeadEisenhower Briefing Document (MJ-12)
A ball of fire fell on the next ranch and started a grass fire; a day or two later a military convoy from Piedras Negras blocked the site and hauled something away.The 1950s Del Rio, Texas UFO CrashesfirsthandSourced, unconfirmedSenor Flores (to Dennis Stacy, Omni 1995)
A national air-defense alert on 6 Dec 1950 reported about 40 unknowns at 32,000 ft, and an FBI memo of 8 Dec records an Army intelligence alert.The 1950s Del Rio, Texas UFO CrashesfirsthandOn the recordAir-defense records and FBI memo, 8 Dec 1950
A USAF document on a recovery flown to Carswell exists.The 1950s Del Rio, Texas UFO CrashesanonymousLeadTodd Zechel
El Indio is not the Willingham case: the dates, places, the state of the wreck and Willingham's posting in Korea all differ.Del Rio 1955The 1950s Del Rio, Texas UFO CrashesanalysisSourced, unconfirmedUAP Gerb (Sam)

Similar cases · sharing people, threads, topics or era

Connected cases

People and organizations

Sources

Mentioned on (2)

A research project by Igor FrancePrivacy